The World of Symphony 5 Beethoven: Symphony No. 5 / Symphony No. 6 is a captivating CD that offers a mix of outstanding and mediocre performances, as highlighted by various customer reviews. The CD features Kurt Sanderling/Berlin Symphony’s rendition of Beethoven’s Symphony No. 5, which has received high praise for its bold, aggressive, and beautiful sound. Sanderling’s interpretation is compared to other renowned recordings and is deemed substantial and impressive. On the other hand, Herbert Kegel’s Dresden Philharmonic Beethoven 6 is described as well-played but somewhat fast for some listeners’ tastes.
One of the standout aspects of this CD is Sanderling’s Beethoven 5th, which is lauded for its propulsive and movingly lyrical performance. The sustained majesty and weight of the orchestral playing, coupled with clear recording, make it a remarkable rendition. However, some customers found Sanderling’s performance to be glib and superficial, lacking the expected weight and flight.
While the Beethoven 5th receives high acclaim, the Beethoven 6th by Kegel is met with mixed reviews. Some listeners appreciate Kegel’s ability to find an ideal tempo throughout the Pastoral Symphony, avoiding extremes and delivering a balanced performance. However, others find it dull or mediocre, lacking the memorability found in other recordings.
Despite the varying opinions on the performances, the CD’s affordability is highlighted, with some customers expressing surprise at finding such exceptional renditions at a low price. The value for money is emphasized, making it an attractive option for those seeking quality recordings without breaking the bank.
In conclusion, the World of Symphony 5 Beethoven: Symphony No. 5 / Symphony No. 6 CD offers a mix of exceptional and average performances, making it a worthwhile addition to a classical music collection, especially considering the affordability and the standout rendition of Beethoven’s Symphony No. 5 by Kurt Sanderling/Berlin Symphony.